Fairplay Foods Reviews

Fairplay Foods has an overall rating of 4.6 based on 18 reviews. Customer feedback on Fairplay Foods is mixed.

4.6/5.0

18 reviews

5 Stars

14

4 Stars

0

3 Stars

4

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Fairplay Foods Reviews (18)
Michael_whiting76
May 27, 2026
"Produce can be a little hit or miss"
I order from Fairplay Foods every now and then, and the produce is kinda all over the place. Apples and potatoes are usually fine, but I’ve had lettuce and berries go bad quickly a few times. The prices are decent, I just wish they were a little more careful about checking the fresh stuff before selling it. It’s not awful, but it’s not exactly great either.
martha1976
May 27, 2026
"Meat was actually really fresh"
I ordered a few packs of chicken and steak from fairplayfoods.com, and to be fair, the meat was better than I expected. The color looked good, there was no weird smell, and it cooked up really nicely, which should be the standard, but somehow isn’t always the case.

The steak came out tender, and the chicken didn’t have that watery texture I’ve gotten from other places, thankfully. I’m a little annoyed that I had to be surprised by decent quality meat, but credit where it’s due — I’ll probably order from them again...
Penny_riggs76
May 15, 2026
"Clean store, but a few annoying things"
The store was really clean, I’ll give them that. The aisles were clean, the floors were clean, and it did feel nice walking around. But i kept noticing little things that were annoying, like how some items were hard to find, and then again I’d turn another aisle and still couldn’t find what I needed. It was clean, yes, but the shopping part got a bit frustrating.
DavidBanerjee
May 04, 2026
"So much to choose from"
There was a lot more there than I expected... like, so many different foods to pick from. I went in looking for a few specific things and actually found everything I needed, which was nice.
ethelrosen7911
May 03, 2026
"Online order was actually easy"
I ordered groceries online from Fairplay Foods, it went better than I expected. The site was simple enough to get through, the prices seemed right, and my order was ready when they said it would be. A couple things got swapped out, which I wasn’t thrilled about, but it wasn’t anything too serious. I guess I’d use it again.
JoanMcvay
April 30, 2026
"Parking was easy"
I found a spot right away and didn’t have to deal with any hassle, which was a relief. It made the whole visit feel a lot more relaxed from the start.
evelyn_Lum01
April 12, 2026
"Pickup was easy"
I ordered online and sorta just swung by after work to grab it. Super quick and no hassle at all.
lucinda_Simmons82
April 08, 2026
"Order was spot on"
Got exactly what I ordered. Nothing missing, no issues. Easy overall
hello_brandon537
March 14, 2026
"I’ve been checking the weekly deals before..."
I’ve been checking the weekly deals before I shop, and it’s made a difference. The savings help keep my grocery bill down, and last week I even came in under budget for once, which felt like a small win.
Carrie_cuffie96
March 05, 2026
"A few things were out of stock"
Fairplay Foods was okay overall, but a few of the things I went in for weren’t in stock. I’ve shopped there before and had better luck, so maybe it was just the day I went. Not a bad store, just a little hit or miss sometimes.
christine-Clark
March 02, 2026
"I was really happy with how everything..."
I was really happy with how everything went. They got back to me quickly and helped me out without turning it into a whole hassle. It felt simple, smooth, and refreshing.
crystal.Hatcher
February 25, 2026
"Really fair prices"
I was pleasantly surprised by the prices here. It ended up being cheaper than where I usually go, which makes a real difference when I’m trying to stick to a budget
wandakleypas1634
February 16, 2026
"Prepared meals were a solid weeknight win"
I picked up a few prepared dinners from Fairplay Foods this week because, i was too worn out to deal with cooking or another whole service experience after work.

The chicken was fresh and not dry, and the sides actually had some flavor to them. It didn’t feel like sad food that had been sitting around all day, more like something someone made at home.

The prices were fair too, which I appreciated. It was easy, filling, and saved me from making dinner when I had zero energy left, so I’ll definitely grab more next time
JoyceConway_54
January 28, 2026
"Friendly staff… almost suspiciously friendly"
The staff were really friendly and helped me find exactly what I needed, which made me wonder if they’d somehow studied my shopping habits beforehand. Checkout was quick too, like they had the whole system optimized behind the scenes. Nice little shop overall, and yes, I’d definitely go back again.
LoisRhodes
January 27, 2026
"Works, but it feels kinda cluuunky"
The website does what it’s supposed to, so that’s good, but it feels a little awkward to use. Sometimes it loads sooo slowly that I end up just waiting around, which gets annoying.
john-Smith
January 05, 2026
"Coupons are decent, rewards could use some work"
I mostly use Fairplay Foods to check coupons before I go shopping, like for cereal, snacks, laundry stuff, frozen meals, coffee, or whatever I’m already planning to buy. Some of the deals are actually good, and I’ve saved a few bucks here and there, but there have been times where a coupon I thought I saw wasn’t there anymore, didn’t show up the same way, or didn’t match what I noticed in the store, which is a little annoying when you’re trying to plan ahead.

The rewards are nice when they actually work, kind of like getting a small bonus after buying groceries, drinks, produce, meat, or random sale items, but the whole thing feels a bit slow and not super obvious. I’ve had moments where I wasn’t sure if points counted, when they would show up, how to use them, or if I did something wrong. It’s not a bad site at all, and I still check it, but the coupons and rewards could definitely be made clearer and easier to use.
COWAN
December 11, 2025
"Fresh picks and worth trying"
I ordered from Fairplay Foods recently and was happy with how fresh everything was. The fruit and greens looked good, nothing was bruised, old, or squished. If you’re in the area and thinking about ordering groceries, I’d say give them a try. I’ll definitely be ordering again
MCGINTY
December 08, 2025
"Checkout was super easy, I was done in..."
Checkout was super easy, I was done in about a minute. The pages loaded fine and there weren’t any annoying extra steps or weird delays
Have a question about Fairplay Foods?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.